Deal of the Week (Dec 15, 2006) Click here for Archives |
Problem: The Auction: West North East South 1♣ 1♥ dbl* pass 2♣ pass 5♣ all pass * Negative Double West led the ♠J. South won the spade lead in hand, and played the King and Ace of Clubs, drawing all the missing trumps. Declarer started eliminating the hand, and unblocked the Ace and King of Diamonds. He now cashed the ♠K and ruffed a spade, and was disappointed to see West discard a heart. If West had held four spades, he could have been thrown in with the fourth spade; a diamond ruff in dummy would have completed the elimination, and declarer would have led the fourth spade discarding a heart from hand, leaving West on play. Since that plan did not come through, declarer ruffed his diamond in dummy, and played a heart. When East alertly contributed the 10 to this trick, declarer knew that the contract had no further chances. He played the ♥K, West won the Ace and quickly cashed two more heart tricks to set the contract. "I was very unlucky, if West had held four spades, he would have been endplayed", South complained. "Alternatively, if West had carelessly discarded a diamond when I ruffed a spade, he could still have been thrown in with the ♦Q. And finally, if West had AQJ10 of hearts, I could still endplay him. When I led a heart from dummy, if East played a small heart, I would have ducked it to West. I tried my best, but they defended very well, the contract cannot be made". "3NT is laydown", observed North thoughtfully. "Yes, there are 9 top tricks", agreed South. "I could not respond 1NT, as I did not have diamonds stopped. If you cue-bid 2♥, I would bid notrumps".
Do you agree with South's remarks?
Declarer should ruff the ♠8 with the ♣Q. West has no good answer. If he discards the ♥4, declarer will exit with a small heart which West will win perforce, and lead away from the ♥A, or play the ♦Q conceding a ruff and discard. If West discards the Queen or Jack of hearts instead, declarer spectacularly exits with the heart King. The defense can win two heart tricks, but cannot take a third trick. It looks as though the discarding ♦Q will save west, but it will only prolong the agony by another trick. Declarer will lead a club to the ten, catching West in a classic one-suit squeeze. If West discards a low heart, declarer will duck a heart, and West has to lead away from the ♥A. If West discards a heart honor, declarer will play a low heart from dummy. If East plays low, the 8 is inserted and West is caught in the familiar dilemma. If East plays the ten, declarer covers the King, and the 9 and 8 are good enought to force one more trick from West's J and 4.
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Regarding the bidding, it is true that North could have probed towards 3NT, but South's 2♣ rebid was the main culprit. With a balanced hand, a heart stopper, and relatively weak clubs, 1NT is the correct bid. The lack of a diamond stopper does not warrant a 2♣ bid, which usually promises a sixth club.
Bridge Baron's Line of Play
Last week, we mentioned about our latest product, Learn and Practice Bidding Conventions. Six different conventions along with their treatments are covered in depth, and millions of practice deals are available for each convention. Common bidding pitfalls, like South's 2♣ rebid in this week's deal, are mentioned as well. This would make a perfect holiday gift for a friend.
Bridge Baron deal No : N1527-12722-56281-82028-28520-81073 |
Name | Comment |
---|---|